Arguments for and against affirmative action essay

The best way to create role models is not to promote people because of race or gender but because they are the best qualified for the job.

History is important when considering governmental rules like Test 21 because low scores by blacks can be traced in large measure to the legacy of slavery and racism: There are brilliant and retarded people in each group. Perhaps these statistics are misleading, but then we need to look carefully at the total evidence.

The Blues fail to practice family planning and have 15 children. Suppose that White policemen overreact to young Black males and the latter group distrust White policemen. Arguments For and Against Affirmative Action "The difficulty of overcoming the effects of past discrimination is as nothing compared with the difficulty of eradicating from our society the source of those effects, which is the tendency -- fatal to a Nation such as ours -- to classify and judge men and women on the basis of their country of origin or the color of their skin.

Consider the sheer rough percentages of those who qualify for Affirmative Action programs.

But, my thesis is, however tragic the situation may be and we may disagree on just how tragic it isone policy is not a legitimate part of the solution and that is reverse, unjust discrimination against young white males.

But the logic is flawed. Rather, given the impossibility of determining what level of representation Blacks would have achieved were it not for racial discrimination, the assumption of proportional representation is the only fair assumption to make. Similarly, the proponents of the doctrine of equal results open the door to a debate over average ability in ethnic, racial and gender groups.

Of course, we might want to distinguish moral from legal desert and argue that, morally speaking, effort is more important than outcome, whereas, legally speaking, outcome may be more important.

It is the policy that is currently being promoted under the name of Affirmative Action, so it I will use that term or "AA" for short throughout this essay to stand for this version of affirmative action. For the first time in my life I offered to make a phone call on his behalf to a university to which he had applied.

If minimal qualifications are not adequate to override excellence in basketball, even when the minimality is a consequence of wrongdoing, why should they be adequate in other areas?

Therefore better qualified people do not deserve their qualifications. Our common humanity should be a sufficient basis for us to see the possibility of success in people of virtue and merit.

The Supreme Court recently refused to rule on the appeal, thus leaving it to the individual states to decide how they will deal with this issue. To see this, reflect that just because I do not deserve the money that I have been given as a gift for instance does not mean that I am not entitled to what I get with that money.

No restraints are put on the Blues regarding family size. And likewise with airplane pilots, military leaders, business executives, and, may I say it, teachers and university professors. Might this not be a reason to reconsider Affirmative Action?

Finally, even if identifiable blacks were harmed by identifiable social practices, it is not clear that most forms of Affirmative Action are appropriate to restore the situation. They can be overridden. The best people for the position should be put there, regardless of race.The Case Against Affirmative Action Louis P.


In this essay I set forth nine arguments against Strong Affirmative Action, which I define as preferential treatment, discriminating in favor of members of under-represented groups, which have been treated unjustly in the past, against innocent people. Aug 23,  · Affirmative action was created to assist minority groups against discrimination, but affirmative action does more harm than what it can do to help.

Affirmative action was created with the intention of leveling the playing field so that everyone can have an equal opportunity to be hired or accepted in to a school, but it. Affirmative action is a way to help compensate for the fact that, due to many years of oppression, some races "started late in the race." Again, it helps level the playing field.

A short essay which contains the typical arguments for affirmative action. Arguments have continually been made for and against the installment of affirmative action.

Affirmative action is an overarching term that refers to the way schools and businesses select employees and students. The positive arguments will be presented along with the negative arguments.

The affects affirmative action has on the society of the United States will be analyzed. - Affirmative Action is Against the Bible America was known as the Land of Opportunity. Argumentative Essay] Free Essays words | ( pages) | Preview. Class Based.

In The Case Against Affirmative Action, the author states, “This same push for ‘diversity’ also has led Stanford to create racially segregated .

Arguments for and against affirmative action essay
Rated 3/5 based on 31 review